Circular Supply Chain: Challenges and Strategies

Circular Supply Chain: Challenges and Strategies

Intrigued by the promise of a cleaner, more profitable supply chain? This blog dives into circular supply chains, revealing real-world examples—from Heineken’s connected breweries to Caterpillar’s modular designs—and unpacks the biggest obstacles that keep manufacturers stuck in linear “take-make-dispose” cycles.
by 
Luke Crihfield

Introduction

According to EY’s C-suite Insights: Sustainability and Environmental, Social and Governance  (ESG) Trends Index of 2023, 50% of executives reported that their organizations are actively developing sustainable supply chains. 

As we approach 2025, the transition to circular supply chains becomes increasingly important amid tightening ESG regulations, evolving sustainability goals, and dynamic market demands. 

In this blog, we examine what a circular supply chain entails, the challenges it faces, and actionable circular strategies for large manufacturers and industrial enterprises.

What Is a Circular Supply Chain?

A circular supply chain is a system designed to keep products, materials, and resources in use for as long as possible and reduce their degenerative impact. Unlike traditional linear supply chains that follow a "take-make-dispose" model, circular supply chains emphasize reusing, refurbishing, recycling, and repurposing assets to reduce waste.

Why Circular Supply Chains Matter in Industry

Let’s explore why transitioning from traditional linear supply chains to circular models is essential for modern industry.

1. Reducing Environmental Impact

By reusing, recycling, and repurposing materials, circular supply chains significantly lower the environmental footprint of industrial operations. It minimizes raw material extraction, reduces waste, and decreases energy consumption and emissions—key factors for meeting both regulatory requirements and corporate sustainability targets.

2. Enhancing Resource Efficiency

Circular supply chains enable companies to maximize the value of every resource. By recycling, reusing, and repurposing machinery, equipment and materials, businesses can boost their operational agility. It provides leeway to industries in directing capital to other resourceful initiatives.

3. Improving Long-Term Cost-Effectiveness

Adopting a circular supply chain model significantly enhances long-term cost-effectiveness by reducing reliance on new raw materials, strategic disposition of surplus industrial inventories to other potential buyers, and lowering waste management expenses. 

4. Aligning with ESG and Compliance Frameworks

Shifting to a circular supply chain fosters ESG alignment by reusing, recycling, and repurposing resources. Companies lower environmental impact, meet regulatory requirements, mitigate non-compliance risks, and build a more sustainable, responsible business model.

Key Challenges in Implementing Circular Supply Chains

Here are the key challenges large enterprises face when transitioning from traditional linear models to circular supply chains.

1. Fragmented Data and Lack of Visibility

Fragmented data and poor tracking of materials, inventory, and asset lifecycles hinder effective decision-making and disrupt circular supply chain processes. Without integrated, real-time visibility, companies miss opportunities to recycle and repurpose assets efficiently, leading to operational inefficiencies and increased costs.

2. Limited Industrial Linkages

Misalignment among value chain stakeholders across industries prevents the effective sharing of surplus and idle equipment across industries. Without strong industrial linkages and platforms, companies miss opportunities to repurpose excess and unused assets, leading to inefficiencies and higher costs.

3. High Upfront Costs and Uncertain ROI

Implementing circular supply chain practices often requires significant initial investments in new technologies, infrastructure, and process redesign. These high upfront costs and uncertain returns can make companies hesitant, even though long-term savings and efficiency gains typically outweigh the initial expenses.

4. Regulatory Complexity

Navigating diverse cross-border regulations for waste management, recycling, and product compliance creates significant challenges. This regulatory complexity can increase operational costs and uncertainty, making it difficult for companies to transition or fully implement circular supply chain practices.

5. Product Design Limitations

Many industrial products are designed for single-use applications without considering reuse or easy disassembly. This lack of design foresight limits opportunities for repurposing or recycling, leading to increased waste and linearity in the supply chain.

6. Cultural Resistance and Organizational Inertia

Implementing circular supply chain practices often faces internal challenges, as traditional mindsets and short-term performance metrics hinder change. Overcoming this resistance requires strong leadership, clear communication, and gradual transformation to build acceptance and trust in new approaches.

Practical Circular Strategies for a Circular Supply Chain Economy

1. Leverage Digital Tools for End-to-End Traceability

Implementing digital tools like IoT sensors, blockchain, and AI-powered ERP systems provides complete visibility across your supply chain. Real-time tracking of inventory, material flows, and asset lifecycles enables you to identify inefficiencies and reduce waste while ensuring full transparency in your circular supply chain. This level of traceability supports sustainable decision-making, and every resource is managed responsibly.

Real-World Example

Global brewer Heineken implemented a Connected Brewery Ecosystem that leverages IoT sensors, data analytics, and digital twin modeling to simulate and analyze a virtual replica of a typical Heineken brewery. Analytics from the digital twin identified measures to curb energy waste and is projected to save 15–20% in energy consumption and approximately a 50% reduction in CO₂ emissions at its production sites on average.

2. Build Long-Term Supplier Partnerships

Long-term supplier partnerships are vital for creating a circular supply chain and for slowly transitioning toward a regenerative supply chain. By collaborating through co-innovation and aligning on shared sustainability goals, companies optimize resource use, drive continuous improvements, and strengthen supply chain resilience.

Real-World Example

Renault (automaker) teamed up with waste management firm SUEZ to create Indra, a joint venture dedicated to recycling end-of-life vehicles (ELVs). This long-term supplier partnership (established in 2008) built France’s leading dismantling network for ELVs, ensuring materials like metals, plastics, and valuable minerals are recovered and fed back into new car production.

3. Adopt Modular Design and Engineering for Reuse

Adopting modular design principles enables industries to extend product lifecycles, minimize waste, and enhance the reusability of components. By designing products with standardized, interchangeable parts that can be easily disassembled, repaired, or upgraded, manufacturers reduce the need for complete replacements and facilitate refurbishment.

Real-World Example

Caterpillar Inc., the construction and mining equipment manufacturer, has embraced design for refurbishment. Heavy machinery is composed of large modules that Caterpillar designs to be rebuilt multiple times. When a Cat engine or part wears out, customers can return the used component to Caterpillar. The component is then disassembled, cleaned, and remanufactured to original specifications with any updated engineering improvements​ , and they re-enter the supply chain as Cat Reman products with like new quality, including a same-as-new warranty

4. Liquidation-Based Circular Procurement

Building on the principles of circular sourcing, liquidation-based procurement transforms surplus industrial assets into working capital and strengthens a circular supply chain. By acquiring idle machinery and excess materials from companies looking to liquidate, businesses conserve resources and promote industrial symbiosis.

Real-World Example

In 2022, Amplio helped Hayden overcome a key component shortage by helping them source the component from their trusted secondary network of industrial sellers. Amplio helped Hayden overcome the issue of component obsolescence and turned idle assets into vital production inputs for them.

5. Surplus Asset Value Recovery

Transforming idle equipment and surplus inventory into valuable resources is a key strategy for enhancing supply chain sustainability. Liquidating tangible assets by manufacturers recovers significant value and makes them available to other industries, reducing waste and storage costs while turning potential liabilities into strategic investments that strengthen the circular economy and foster industrial symbiosis.

Real-World Example

A Fortune 500 paper manufacturer faced mounting surplus equipment and materials across over 90 mills, which tied up valuable capital and warehouse space. Rather than scrapping these functional assets, the company partnered with Amplio to execute a structured liquidation strategy. In just six months, Amplio’s dedicated team cleared surplus from 21 sites and doubled asset recovery rates compared to previous methods. By selling idle machinery to other industrial users, the manufacturer unlocked significant capital that was reinvested in new production initiatives while advancing circular economy practices through the productive reuse of assets.

How Amplio Facilitates an Industrial Circular Supply Chain

Amplio’s data-driven platform transforms idle industrial assets into strategic resources, supporting a more sustainable supply chain. Our services bridge industrial buyers and sellers while reducing waste and unlocking value from underutilized equipment. Our circular services focus on providing:

  1. Streamlined Liquidation and Redeployment

We streamline the liquidation process by efficiently redeploying surplus machinery and equipment. By redirecting idle assets to markets where they are needed, we keep valuable resources in circulation.

  1. Marketplace for Surplus Assets

Our dedicated platform connects verified sellers with industrial buyers. The marketplace-like model enables businesses to access surplus assets at competitive prices, driving resource efficiency and supporting a circular economy.

  1. Enabling Circular Procurement from Industrial Idle Sources

Amplio functions as well as empowers procurement teams to source high-quality surplus equipment directly from idle inventories. We help enterprise buyers reduce procurement costs and optimize resource allocation while meeting sustainability objectives.

  1. Obsolescence Management and Inventory Recovery

We help manage obsolescence by recovering and liquidating outdated equipment before it loses value. Timely inventory recovery converts potential waste into working capital, enhancing supply chain efficiency and reducing environmental impact.

Conclusion: Moving from Linear to Circular

Transitioning to circular supply chains is no longer just about sustainability—it’s a strategic move that improves operational efficiency, reduces costs, and strengthens resilience. 

Starting with practical steps like asset recovery or procurement audits helps organizations identify untapped value and accelerate progress toward circularity. 

Regulatory pressures and market expectations are likely to grow in the future, and companies adopting circular models will gain a lasting competitive edge while driving meaningful environmental and economic impact.

Get updates to your inbox.

Get the latest industry benchmarks and keep learning about your assets' value
We never share your data.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.